|
Rep. Maura Hirschauer
Filed: 3/24/2026
| | 10400HB4248ham001 | | LRB104 16598 SPS 34912 a |
|
|
| 1 | | AMENDMENT TO HOUSE BILL 4248
|
| 2 | | AMENDMENT NO. ______. Amend House Bill 4248 by replacing |
| 3 | | everything after the enacting clause with the following: |
| 4 | | "Section 1. Short title. This Act may be cited as the |
| 5 | | Algorithmic Pricing Transparency Act. |
| 6 | | Section 5. Legislative findings. The General Assembly |
| 7 | | finds and declares: |
| 8 | | (1) Consumers increasingly purchase goods and services |
| 9 | | through online platforms that collect and process browsing |
| 10 | | behavior, geolocation data, purchase history, and other |
| 11 | | personal data. |
| 12 | | (2) Businesses use automated systems and data-driven |
| 13 | | algorithms to generate prices that may vary among |
| 14 | | consumers for the same goods or services. |
| 15 | | (3) These practices, sometimes referred to as |
| 16 | | "surveillance pricing", may limit a consumer's ability to |
|
| | 10400HB4248ham001 | - 2 - | LRB104 16598 SPS 34912 a |
|
|
| 1 | | comparison-shop and may enable pricing based on a |
| 2 | | consumer's perceived willingness to pay. |
| 3 | | (4) Transparency regarding the use of personal data in |
| 4 | | pricing practices is necessary to promote fair dealing, |
| 5 | | consumer protection, and market integrity. |
| 6 | | Section 10. Definitions. In this Act: |
| 7 | | "Algorithmic pricing" means a price for goods or services |
| 8 | | generated, in whole or in part, using an automated decision |
| 9 | | system, machine-learning model, or data-driven algorithm. |
| 10 | | "Baseline price" means the price for goods or services |
| 11 | | made available to consumers by a covered entity, excluding any |
| 12 | | discounts, coupons, promotional offers, limited-time sales, |
| 13 | | rebates, loyalty or club member pricing, or other reductions |
| 14 | | or incentives offered to the consumer that lower the total |
| 15 | | amount the consumer pays for the goods or services. "Baseline |
| 16 | | price" does not include a higher price for goods or services |
| 17 | | made available to consumers by a covered entity for the |
| 18 | | purpose of offering a lower price through surveillance pricing |
| 19 | | or algorithmic pricing. "Baseline price" does not include any |
| 20 | | additional fees for premium or additional features. |
| 21 | | "Clear and conspicuous" means a disclosure that is easily |
| 22 | | noticeable, understandable, and proximate to the pricing |
| 23 | | information presented to the consumer. |
| 24 | | "Covered entity" means any person or entity that sells or |
| 25 | | offers to sell goods or services through an online platform to |
|
| | 10400HB4248ham001 | - 3 - | LRB104 16598 SPS 34912 a |
|
|
| 1 | | consumers in this State. |
| 2 | | "Personal data" means information linked or reasonably |
| 3 | | linkable to a consumer, including, but not limited to, |
| 4 | | browsing history, search queries, geolocation data, prior |
| 5 | | purchases, digital identifiers, or demographic profile data. |
| 6 | | "Personalized price increase" means a price for goods or |
| 7 | | services that is higher than the baseline price and is set for |
| 8 | | a consumer based on the consumer's personal data. |
| 9 | | "Surveillance pricing" means algorithmic pricing that uses |
| 10 | | a consumer's personal data to generate a personalized price |
| 11 | | increase. "Surveillance pricing" does not include any methods |
| 12 | | of lowering the baseline price for goods or services, |
| 13 | | including, but not limited to: |
| 14 | | (1) the application of any discounts, coupons, |
| 15 | | promotional offers, rebates, limited-time sales, loyalty |
| 16 | | or club member pricing, or other reductions or incentives |
| 17 | | offered to the consumer that lower the total amount the |
| 18 | | consumer pays; |
| 19 | | (2) price comparison tools, competitor price matching, |
| 20 | | or other comparison-based pricing mechanisms; or |
| 21 | | (3) any other price reduction method that does not |
| 22 | | increase the baseline price to the consumer. |
| 23 | | Section 15. Mandatory disclosure of surveillance pricing. |
| 24 | | (a) A covered entity shall provide a clear and conspicuous |
| 25 | | disclosure if the baseline price for a specific consumer is |
|
| | 10400HB4248ham001 | - 4 - | LRB104 16598 SPS 34912 a |
|
|
| 1 | | personalized and generated using surveillance pricing. The |
| 2 | | disclosure must state: THIS PRICE WAS SET BY AN ALGORITHM |
| 3 | | USING YOUR PERSONAL DATA. |
| 4 | | (b) The disclosure required under subsection (a) shall be |
| 5 | | considered proximate to the pricing information if it is |
| 6 | | presented next to the price, at the point of checkout, or |
| 7 | | through a notice presented before completion of the |
| 8 | | transaction. |
| 9 | | Section 20. Consumer rights. |
| 10 | | (a) A consumer may opt out of surveillance pricing. |
| 11 | | (b) Upon request, a covered entity shall provide the |
| 12 | | consumer with a non-personalized baseline price for the goods |
| 13 | | or services. |
| 14 | | Section 25. Prohibited conduct. |
| 15 | | (a) A covered entity shall not use the following |
| 16 | | information to generate algorithmic pricing: |
| 17 | | (1) race; |
| 18 | | (2) religion; |
| 19 | | (3) sexual orientation; |
| 20 | | (4) immigration status; |
| 21 | | (5) medical information; or |
| 22 | | (6) criminal history. |
| 23 | | (b) A covered entity shall not engage in deceptive or |
| 24 | | misleading personalized pricing practices. |
|
| | 10400HB4248ham001 | - 5 - | LRB104 16598 SPS 34912 a |
|
|
| 1 | | (c) A covered entity shall not inflate baseline prices or |
| 2 | | impose penalties on consumers who opt out of surveillance |
| 3 | | pricing under subsection (a) of Section 20. |
| 4 | | Section 30. Exceptions. |
| 5 | | (a) This Act does not apply to price changes that are the |
| 6 | | result of: |
| 7 | | (1) fluctuations in the cost of acquiring, producing, |
| 8 | | transporting, or distributing inventory, including, but |
| 9 | | not limited to, changes in wholesale prices, manufacturing |
| 10 | | costs, labor, insurance, or other input costs associated |
| 11 | | with providing goods or services to different consumers; |
| 12 | | (2) objective cost differences directly related to the |
| 13 | | provision, supply, or sale of goods or services to |
| 14 | | consumers in different geographic areas, market regions, |
| 15 | | or delivery locations, including, but not limited to, |
| 16 | | reasonable variations reflecting the costs or conditions |
| 17 | | associated with serving particular areas or responding to |
| 18 | | differing levels of supply or demand; |
| 19 | | (3) supply chain disruptions, including, but not |
| 20 | | limited to, delays, shortages, allocation by suppliers, |
| 21 | | changes in shipping modes or routes, or other logistical |
| 22 | | constraints that reasonably affect the seller's costs or |
| 23 | | available quantities; |
| 24 | | (4) time-limited sales, promotions, or discounts that |
| 25 | | are offered in good faith and in the usual course of the |
|
| | 10400HB4248ham001 | - 6 - | LRB104 16598 SPS 34912 a |
|
|
| 1 | | seller's business, including introductory pricing, |
| 2 | | seasonal or clearance sales, and advertised promotional |
| 3 | | events; |
| 4 | | (5) the imposition, repeal, or adjustment of any tax, |
| 5 | | fee, surcharge, or assessment imposed by federal, State, |
| 6 | | or local law, or any pass-through of such amounts to the |
| 7 | | consumer; |
| 8 | | (6) variations in shipping, delivery, or handling |
| 9 | | costs, including fuel surcharges and carrier rate changes, |
| 10 | | and any pass-through of such costs to the consumer; |
| 11 | | (7) loyalty, membership, or rewards programs, |
| 12 | | including differentiated pricing based on participation in |
| 13 | | the programs, use of digital coupons, or accumulation or |
| 14 | | redemption of rewards, if the terms are disclosed and |
| 15 | | applied in a non-discriminatory manner; |
| 16 | | (8) special discount programs, including |
| 17 | | differentiated pricing offered to individuals who meet |
| 18 | | publicly disclosed eligibility criteria, such as teachers, |
| 19 | | employees, active-duty or retired military personnel, |
| 20 | | senior citizens, and students; |
| 21 | | (9) any fees, surcharges, or other charges that are |
| 22 | | imposed or set by third parties, including payment |
| 23 | | processors, delivery platforms, or other intermediaries, |
| 24 | | and any pass-through of such amounts to the consumer; or |
| 25 | | (10) any other bona fide price change that is |
| 26 | | reasonably attributable to legitimate business |
|
| | 10400HB4248ham001 | - 7 - | LRB104 16598 SPS 34912 a |
|
|
| 1 | | considerations, including changes in market demand, |
| 2 | | competitive conditions, or the seller's cost structure, if |
| 3 | | the price change is applied in a non-discriminatory manner |
| 4 | | to similarly situated consumers. |
| 5 | | (b) This Act does not apply to algorithmic pricing models |
| 6 | | that do not use personal data, including models based on |
| 7 | | aggregate market demand. |
| 8 | | (c) This Act does not apply to: |
| 9 | | (1) any insurer or affiliate of the insurer or any |
| 10 | | artificial intelligence system, algorithmic pricing |
| 11 | | system, or surveillance pricing system deployed by or on |
| 12 | | behalf of an insurer or affiliate of the insurer; or |
| 13 | | (2) providers of financial services, including, but |
| 14 | | not limited to, financial institutions, financial |
| 15 | | institution affiliates, broker-dealers, registered |
| 16 | | investment advisors, and entities that provide consumer |
| 17 | | credit products, including credit cards, personal loans, |
| 18 | | and mortgages. |
| 19 | | The provisions of paragraph (1) apply to any insurer or |
| 20 | | affiliate of the insurer that is regulated by the Department |
| 21 | | of Insurance. Nothing in the paragraph shall be construed to |
| 22 | | delegate regulatory oversight over any insurer or affiliate of |
| 23 | | an insurer to any State agency other than the Department of |
| 24 | | Insurance. |
| 25 | | Section 35. Enforcement. A violation of any of the |
|
| | 10400HB4248ham001 | - 8 - | LRB104 16598 SPS 34912 a |
|
|
| 1 | | provisions of this Act is an unlawful practice under the |
| 2 | | Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act. All |
| 3 | | remedies, penalties, and authority granted to the Attorney |
| 4 | | General by that Act shall be available to him or her for the |
| 5 | | enforcement of this Act. |
| 6 | | Section 40. Home rule. The regulation of algorithmic |
| 7 | | pricing, surveillance pricing, or any other similar pricing |
| 8 | | mechanism is an exclusive power and function of the State. A |
| 9 | | home rule unit may not regulate algorithmic pricing, |
| 10 | | surveillance pricing, or any other similar pricing mechanism. |
| 11 | | This Section is a denial and limitation of home rule powers and |
| 12 | | functions under subsection (h) of Section 6 of Article VII of |
| 13 | | the Illinois Constitution. |
| 14 | | Section 45. Rulemaking. The Attorney General shall adopt |
| 15 | | rules to implement and administer this Act. |
| 16 | | Section 50. Relation to other laws. Nothing in this Act |
| 17 | | shall be construed to limit any federal or State law. |
| 18 | | Section 90. The Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business |
| 19 | | Practices Act is amended by adding Section 2MMMM as follows: |
| 20 | | (815 ILCS 505/2MMMM new) |
| 21 | | Sec. 2MMMM. Violations of the Algorithmic Pricing |